Reforming Islam?

by | Mar 9, 2016 | Uncategorized | 76 comments

Reforming Islam?

Yassin al-Haj Saleh is a celebrated Syrian writer and political dissident who spent sixteen years and fourteen days in jail at the behest of Hafez al-Assad’s regime for being a member of the Communist Party. He, like Tony Abbott, believes there needs to be a ‘religious reformation in Islam’; however, his progressivism couldn’t be more different than Abbott’s reactionary divisiveness.

While al-Haj Saleh argues that ‘[m]any Muslims, many Islamists, are essentialist’, Abbott has displayed a penchant for invoking the views of Egyptian coup leader President Abdel Fattah el-Sisi, a man who as head of the army ordered the systematic murder of unarmed political protestors in Rabaa Square in August 2013. (Human Rights Watch has described the killings as probable crimes against humanity.)

Indeed, Abbott’s position has much more in common with the ultra-conservative elements within Islam he claims to be denouncing. As al-Haj Saleh explains in ‘Armed Words’, an interview recently published in The New Inquiry:

…many critics of Islam are essentialist in their own way. Even though some of them are thinking about Islam on the basis of modernity or secularism, there is nothing radical about their critiques—they are not interested in human dignity, equality, freedom, or justice.

For Abbott, Islam (and, by extension, Muslims) is something that needs to be tamed, so that order and stability can be restored.

His abiding belief that what’s also needed is a ‘restoration of cultural self-confidence in those who are supporters of Western civilisation’ is further evidence that ‘clash of civilisations’ commentary almost always emanates from the West as it casts its gaze East. The commentariat never talks about imperialism as a ‘clash of civilisations’, despite the fact that it caused (and continues to cause) incalculable destruction and suffering.

For Abbott, the West is civilised (and civilises), while those in the East are marauding barbarians. His lack of historical perspective and his Western bias are staggering, yet this is hardly surprising for those who observed his prime ministership. He has shown little regard for those who suggest that the West’s meddling in the Middle East has played a role in the creation of the Islamic State.

Similarly, beyond pontificating that ‘all cultures are not created equal’, he offers little in the way of reasons as to why, as he says, ‘Islam has never had…a Reformation, an Enlightenment [and] a well-developed concept of the separation of church and state’.

Al-Haj Saleh, by contrast, understands the complexities involved in his calls for a ‘religious reformation in Islam’, saying in the New Inquiry interview:

Now Islam, in our modern experiences, has been in many instances a tool of resistance against colonialism, against Western hegemony, and this prevented many of us from fighting against the problems within Islam, things related to the inequalities between men and women, for instances, between Muslims and non-Muslims, and things related to legitimizing absolute power and tyranny.

He understands culture—or what Jürgen Habermas conceptualised as the public sphere—to be a field for strategic struggle, in which ideas carry weight and have the potential to enact change:

…we have three monsters in Syria, three inhuman creatures. One, the Islamic monster, second, the monster of Tyranny. And third, the Western Imperialist monster. And culture can be our weapon to remake these monsters into human energies, human politics, human actors. Culture is a humanizing field to transform these monsters to human-scale powers.

This is a universalist conception of culture, not the divisive one propagated by Abbott.

Moreover, among al-Haj Saleh’s preconditions for a ‘religious reformation in Islam’, Abbott—who supported the Iraq war and has called for Australian ‘boots on the ground’ in Syria—is part of ‘the Western Imperialist monster’ that needs to be denounced. In other words, the challenges in reforming Islam are part of the same struggle against the kind of resurgent fascism that has become acceptable in the Western mainstream.

Abbott’s us-versus-them approach fits neatly within hundreds of years of Western cultural dominance. It’s given us endless wars and cost countless lives, and it’s always the Other that’s left to pick up the pieces when it goes horribly wrong.

Al-Haj Saleh suggests that maybe these wars and deaths can be somehow harnessed to achieve a greater good:

And to do this [make the world a better place], cultural revolution, suffering, the experience of those who have been killed, crushed, suffered, are an important basis for this. And you can challenge the religious authorities, the powers, in the name of this suffering. This is the real basis for a new humanity, and hopefully a new thinking, a new culture.

Al-Haj Saleh and many other progressive Muslims continue to struggle against the fanaticism within the Islamic tradition. They understand that change always needs to happen from the bottom up if it’s to be long-lasting. Abbott and his cohort, on the hand, offer a kind of faux-humanitarian authoritarianism as the answer, which will ultimately lead only to more death, destruction and suffering.

The challenge for progressives in the West is to continue to rail against the likes of Abbott, who use the wars in the Middle East as an excuse to inflame fear, incite hatred and promote further war. To speak out is a gesture of solidarity with those suffering under the Islamic State and the Assad regime, and it is also part of the broader project to create what al-Haj Saleh calls ‘a new humanist culture’.

 

(This was originally published in Arena Magazine, No.140, 02 2016–3 2016.)

76 Comments

  5. margaritabx4
    margaritabx4 on January 19, 2019 at 6:13 pm

    New sexy website is available on the web
    http://british.porn.fetlifeblog.com/?aileen

    bizarre deviant horrific porn pierced nipples dreadlocks back tatoo porn jays xxx porn free best blowjobs porn tube longest romantic gang bang porn torrents

  12. rebekahcd18
    rebekahcd18 on January 27, 2019 at 2:56 am

    Browse over 500 000 of the best porn galleries, daily updated collections
    http://ukdating.fetlifeblog.com/?devin

    german porn actresses frre young porn pics teenie extream porn tubes free kiddie porn video downloads aebn watchfree gay porn

  13. RCHlifelf
    RCHlifelf on January 28, 2019 at 3:58 am

    Магазин ФМ Чемпион – динамично растущая коммерческая знаменитая компания, работающая на Русском экономическом рынке больше 8лет.

    Вам нужны садовые инструменты и техника для дачного домика, но не знаете,какая конкретно эффективнее и где её покупать? Мы вам делаем отличное предложение побывать наш интернет магазин ФМ Чемпион. В интернет магазине значительный ассортимент ТРАКТОРА. Когда вы лично задумались сегодня купить Электроножницы наш магазин покажет вам все модели товара.

    Магазин ФМ Чемпион это то место где можно купить все для дома начиная с Прочие агрегаты и заканчивая МОЙКАМИ ВЫСОКОГО ДАВЛЕНИЯ.

    Заказать садовое сложную технику и инструменты в представленном веб магазине на портале возможно по будням и выходным Транспортировка каждого агрегата при закупочной цене от 9 тысяч рублей происходит по городу бесплатно. Мы готовы предоставить сертификат гарантии на все изделия, которые конкретно сейчас есть в нашем магазине ФМ Чемпион. Рассылка бытовых товаров по нужному адресу производится в течении суток до пяти суток с момента заказа. Сроки зависят от города, подобную информацию уточнит оператор интернет магазина.

    Официальный сайт чемпион в России – двигатель champion g033htf ii

  17. MalyRix
    MalyRix on January 31, 2019 at 12:57 pm

    Приветствую!!Специально для Вас сделал подборку очень полезной информации этот такой конечно, заниматься можно и за большим письменным столом, и даже на кухне за обеденным, но за своим маленьким столиком ребенку будет не только комфортнее, но и куда интереснее!из напитков выбираем: чай, соки из нейтральных или сладких овощей и фруктов, компоты из сухофруктов.

  27. keriab1
    keriab1 on February 8, 2019 at 12:12 am

    Enjoy our scandal amateur galleries that looks incredibly dirty
    http://bbw.lesbians.allproblog.com/?madisen

    free tocking porn interracial bi cuckold porn video spunk porn powered by phpbb my lesbian story porn ryder porn

  30. Chrisdrupe
    Chrisdrupe on February 13, 2019 at 12:53 pm

    uk cvv – verifed seller cvv, cvv2 dump

  35. bettyjt11
    bettyjt11 on February 18, 2019 at 3:30 am

    Scandal porn galleries, daily updated lists
    http://porn.cartoons.bloglag.com/?diana

    forbidden illegal young teen porn video porn young leaf japanese gravure model tricked into porn catsuit porn sex maxx porn xxx

  37. Tourist
    Tourist on February 18, 2019 at 12:45 pm

    Если вам нравится путешествовать или вы просто увлекаетесь туризмом,
    то вам будет интересна информация предоставленная на нашем сайте
    http://touristservices.ru Здесь вы сможете воспользоваться такими услугами как:
    бронирование отелей, поиск авиабилетов, выбор и заказ морских круизов, трансфер
    до аэропорта или попросту такси,экскурсии и прокат авто. Планируйте свой отдых
    самостоятельно и без посредников, экономя до 30 процентов на каждой услуге.

  43. SVStitle
    SVStitle on February 25, 2019 at 11:02 am

    Некоторые из скважин со временем проведения восстановительного комплекса действий смогут быть снова введены в использование. Тем более что стоимость объекта подобных действий в десятки раз ниже общей стоимости самих сооружений.
    Гарантировано повышение сбыта водозаборной скважины не менее тридцати процентовЫ от имеющегося на момент старта выполненных работ.

    В восьмидесятиS% случаях скважины восстанавливаются до начальных данных при включении в применение скважины, что несомненно является альтернативой производства буровых работ новой скважины.

    Наши сотрудники фирмы по Очистке КНС (Канализационно-насосная станция) и Демонтажу аварийного оборудования из водозаборной скважины предлагаем свои услуги всем, как частным так и общественным органам.

    Спец вод сервис : телеинспекция труб купить

  44. Sprintitle
    Sprintitle on February 27, 2019 at 12:45 am

    A modern cleaning famous company consists of professional and mobile specialists on cleaning Cleaning the garage . In a matter of hours all of them ready Tidy up office List of Works cleaningspecialized company in Staten Island. Huge set work and specially prepared technology allows easy and simple to create atmosphere cleanliness in any cottage.
    The Tidying up home on Cobble Hill cleaning by the firm now – this is simply.
    Every modern self-respecting international company will place detailed advertising information about its activities on internet. Our the firm cleaning contains detailed data about provided works, cost, work order, use means.
    CLEANING SERVICE famous company produces cleaning of apartments any areas and different destination for private citizens. Our employees firms hover ideal in room.

    Specialists “Cleaning Service” always ready decide every task, associated with guidance order. You always always can call in “Cleaning Service” – we well to cope with the work of any size.

    This is a whole a extremely large cleaning, she will leave your personal penthouse flawless. Whether you’re , moving you or notClean Master able there to help to get any new apartment pure view.

    Housekeeping tips Flatiron – spring cleaning service

  45. neilpn1
    neilpn1 on February 27, 2019 at 7:42 pm

    Sexy photo galleries, daily updated collections
    http://animatedporn.xblognetwork.com/?arely

    data base of gay porn stars black ametuer porn best porn sites streaming best gay porn in the world jennifer love hewitt porn video

  47. BestDwight
    BestDwight on February 28, 2019 at 1:28 pm

    I see you don’t monetize your blog, don’t waste your traffic, you can earn extra bucks
    every month. If you want to read about this method, simply
    search in gooogle: dracko’s tricks

  49. Cleantitle
    Cleantitle on March 2, 2019 at 12:26 am

    Our Cleaning production company is giving great attention professionalismall our own employees and tracks the timely increase of their vocational training. Presented professionals in their field available the most challenging works, workers can help make cleanliness everywhere in cottage.
    Pick suitable for you work schedule – day / evening / night.

    Maid is private housekeeper, she comes at suitable for client time and does the list in advance of the stipulated of tasks. It is now fashionable service, which can allow to maintain apartment or house in order, not wasting all remaining time on the decision household problems. AT case ifyou need coming worker Radio Row, we provide her just for you.

    ourfirms you have the opportunity order worker- “maid service” Midtown East two times in one week . Housekeeper will come to your apartment / house / office in advance agreed time , and commit defined list of processes . To you remains required evaluate high quality implementedservices and enjoy cleaned and comfortable apartment.

    Commercial maid service NYC – Maids Manhattan

  52. KRtitle
    KRtitle on March 2, 2019 at 7:33 pm

    Each room apartments, houses, cottages or other housing Sunnyside unique and carries own high-functional load. And this setting mostly concerns modern kitchens.
    90s kitchen remodel of course most energy consuming business in any room
    In our company Sole Partnership DORTY Bensonhurst involved trained specialists, who much know about Kitchen home renovations.
    We design original interiors , giving great attention torequirements reliability and functionality . We are cooperating with customer on all absolutely stages execute multilateral analysis of features rooms , carry advance calculations.You are interested in questions .

    The International Company always ready to provide high-quality Kitchen remodel for less than $5000 by affordable costs. Specialists with great professional experience work no doubt help whole change in a matter of days . The price depends on selected style of kitchen.

    Countertop renovation cheap Gramercy Square : kitchen renovation Prospect Hights

  53. shirleyph2
    shirleyph2 on March 5, 2019 at 1:12 pm

    Browse over 500 000 of the best porn galleries, daily updated collections
    http://hdporn.relayblog.com/?kiana

    beach hd porn plrn tube like youtube stockings ribbons porn free mobile porn site directories amatuer porn cam

  58. magdalenahx11
    magdalenahx11 on March 9, 2019 at 11:07 am

    Dirty Porn Photos, daily updated galleries
    http://porn.bloglag.com/?tiara

    xxx couples porn online videos free arabic porn sites free interracial porn sites hot bisexual porn torrents streaming porn rim job party

  67. RobertoHon
    RobertoHon on March 15, 2019 at 9:43 pm

    de chirico train – the lodge painting piere auguste renor, spranger mars venus and cupid

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published.